Buying a used car with AWD usually means paying a premium, unless you’re shopping Subaru. Almost every Subaru on the road comes with all-wheel drive as standard equipment, not as a $2,000 option you have to haggle for. That makes used Subaru models one of the smartest places to look if you want traction, reliability, and real-world value.
This guide breaks down the best picks by model, what years to target, what to watch out for, and how to make sure you’re getting a solid deal. Whether you’re eyeing a rugged outback adventure rig or just want something dependable in the snow, there’s a used Subaru that fits.
Why a Used Subaru is a Smart Buy
Subaru has built its reputation on two things: all-wheel drive and reliability. Unlike most brands where AWD is an expensive upgrade, Subaru includes it standard on nearly every model they sell. You get better traction in rain, snow, and on unpaved roads without paying extra for it.
That’s not just a marketing line. Subaru consistently earns IIHS Top Safety Pick+ ratings, and their EyeSight driver-assist system has been available since the mid-2010s, which means even older used models often come loaded with real safety tech. Consumer Reports frequently ranks Subarus near the top for owner satisfaction, which tells you something about how these cars hold up over time.
There’s also the boxer engine to consider. Subaru uses a horizontally opposed “boxer” four-cylinder in most of their lineup. It sits lower in the chassis than a traditional engine, which improves handling and lowers the center of gravity. It’s a different design than most cars, and it contributes to the way Subarus feel planted and predictable on the road.
People who buy Subarus tend to keep them. That loyalty drives strong resale values, but it also means you’re buying into a community with a lot of shared knowledge about common issues, maintenance, and upgrades.
Best Used Subaru Models to Buy for Value and Reliability
Not every Subaru is created equal. Some model years are stronger than others, and some body styles suit certain buyers better. Here’s where to focus your search.
Subaru Outback
The outback is the easiest recommendation on this list. It’s the most popular Subaru sold in America, and for good reason. You get a raised wagon body with genuine AWD, decent ground clearance, and a spacious interior that works for families, outdoor gear, and road trips.
Target model year ranges from 2016 onward. The 2016 and 2017 outback received updated safety technology including EyeSight, and the 2020 redesign brought a bigger touchscreen and improved driver aids. The 2023 Subaru Outback is a strong option if your budget allows, with modern tech and plenty of warranty life still remaining on many examples.
The Subaru Outback also holds its value well, so don’t expect rock-bottom pricing. But compared to a similarly sized SUV from other brands with AWD, it’s still a better deal on a per-mile and per-year basis for most buyers.
Subaru Forester
The forester is the SUV of the Subaru lineup, and it has a loyal following for good reason. The interior feels big for its footprint, the visibility is excellent, and the reliability track record is strong across most model years.
The 2008 Subaru Forester is specifically worth mentioning if you’re on a tight budget. According to CarBuzz, the 2008 model year had only one recall to its name and a notably low number of complaints logged with NHTSA. For an older vehicle, that’s a good sign.
If your budget is a bit higher, the 2019 and newer forester is the sweet spot. Subaru redesigned the platform that year, improving rigidity and adding a lot of tech that older generations lacked. The forester from 2019 onward also has better standard safety features, which matters for everyday driving.
The forester is consistently one of the best used Subaru picks for families who want something easy to live with and simple to maintain.
Subaru Crosstrek
The crosstrek sits below the forester in size but above the impreza in ride height. It’s become one of the most popular used Subaru choices for buyers who want something compact but still capable off the pavement.
The Subaru Crosstrek runs on the same AWD system as the rest of the lineup, and it has more ground clearance than most competitors in its class. The 2019 Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid is an interesting option if you’re looking for better fuel economy. It pairs a small battery with the standard AWD setup, which gives you a small efficiency boost without sacrificing traction.
The crosstrek is also one of the more affordable entry points into the used Subaru market, which makes it popular with younger buyers and first-time owners. Just make sure the specific example you’re looking at has been properly maintained, since high-mileage crosstreks can show wear on CVT transmissions if the fluid changes weren’t kept up.
Subaru Impreza
The Subaru Impreza is the foundation of the whole lineup. It’s available as both a sedan and a hatchback, and it comes with AWD as standard equipment even at the base trim level. That’s rare for a compact car, and it’s what makes the impreza worth considering even though it’s the most affordable Subaru model in the lineup.
The 2016 Subaru Impreza and the 2021 Subaru Impreza are both solid choices depending on your budget. The 2016 impreza represents good value for buyers who don’t need the latest tech, while the 2021 sits on the newer global platform and has noticeably better refinement and safety features.
If you’re choosing between the sedan and hatchback body style, the hatchback is the more practical pick for most people. The cargo area is more usable, and the versatility adds everyday utility without giving up much in terms of driving feel.
Other Models Worth Knowing
The 2022 Subaru Legacy is a sedan that often gets overlooked because buyers flock to the crossovers. That works in your favor if you want a comfortable AWD family sedan at a fair price. The Legacy shares a lot of DNA with the outback and delivers a quieter, more car-like experience.
The 2021 Subaru WRX is in its own category. It’s a performance-focused AWD sedan with a turbocharged engine and a strong enthusiast following. Reliability is generally good, but buying a used WRX means being extra careful about how the previous owner drove and maintained it. Get a pre-purchase inspection from an independent mechanic before committing.
The 2013 Subaru Tribeca is one to approach carefully. It was Subaru’s three-row SUV attempt, and it was discontinued in 2014. Parts availability and long-term support aren’t as strong as the forester or outback, and it’s generally not considered one of the better used Subaru options for most buyers.
What to Look for When Buying a Used Subaru
Subarus are reliable, but that doesn’t mean every used example is problem-free. There are a few specific things to check before you hand over any money.
Head gasket issues affected some older Subaru models, particularly those built before 2011. If you’re looking at a high-mileage older forester, outback, or impreza from that era, ask for maintenance records and have a mechanic check for signs of coolant leaks or overheating history.
CVT transmission health matters a lot on newer models. The continuously variable transmission that Subaru uses in most of their lineup is reliable when properly maintained, but fluid changes are often skipped by neglectful owners. Ask when the CVT fluid was last changed and factor in the cost if it hasn’t been done recently.
Oil consumption was a documented problem in some 2011-2014 Subaru models. Check the oil level on any used car you’re considering and ask the seller when it was last topped off between changes.
Run a free VIN lookup on any vehicle you’re seriously considering. It will show you recall history, title issues, and reported accidents. Then follow that up with a physical inspection from an independent mechanic before you sign anything.
Check the NHTSA recalls database for the specific model year you’re considering. Some recalls are minor, but others affect safety systems directly and should be completed before you take ownership.
AWD vs. 4WD: Understanding What Subaru Offers
Buyers sometimes ask whether Subaru’s system is AWD or 4WD, and it’s a fair question. Subaru uses a full-time AWD system, not a part-time 4WD setup like you’d find on a traditional truck-based off-roader. That means all four wheels are always receiving power, automatically adjusted based on traction conditions.
It doesn’t have the same rock-crawling capability as a dedicated 4WD system, but for most buyers, it’s more practical. You don’t have to flip a switch or think about it. It just works in snow, rain, gravel, and light trails. That’s why Subarus are so popular in places with cold winters and unpaved roads.
Subarus are not front-wheel-drive vehicles. The AWD system is always engaged, and there’s no FWD-only mode. That’s one of the key things that separates Subaru from competitors who offer AWD only as an upgrade on otherwise front-wheel-drive platforms.
How to Find the Best Deals on Used Subarus
Timing matters when buying a used Subaru. Inventory tends to move quickly because demand is consistent, so being ready to act when you find a solid example is important. Have your financing sorted out in advance so you’re not scrambling. Use our car loan calculator to figure out what monthly payment fits your budget before you start looking at listings.
When you’re comparing specific models, browsing by make is the fastest way to filter down to what you actually want. You can browse used cars by make to see what’s available across thousands of vehicles in the database and compare options side by side.
Don’t skip the negotiation step. Used Subarus hold their value well, but there’s almost always room to move on price if you can point to deferred maintenance, higher mileage, or cosmetic issues. A pre-purchase inspection report from a mechanic is one of the most useful negotiating tools you can have in hand.
A Final Word on the Best Used Subaru to Buy
If you want one recommendation, the outback wins for most buyers. It’s versatile, reliable, genuinely capable in bad weather, and available in a wide range of model year options to fit different budgets. The forester is the better call if you want more SUV feel and cargo space. The crosstrek makes sense if you want something smaller and easier to park. And the impreza is the budget-friendly entry point that still gets you real AWD.
The best used Subaru for you depends on how you drive, where you live, and what you’re willing to spend. But across the used Subaru models available right now, you’re working with a lineup that consistently delivers reliability and all-weather confidence that most other brands can’t match at the same price point.
Get your VIN check done, book that independent inspection, and don’t let a good example sit while you’re still thinking about it. Solid used Subarus move fast.
Was this helpful?
Put it to work. Research your next car or browse our top gear picks.